Official Bookie Challenge Message Board
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

After further review I say NO TD

4 posters

Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty After further review I say NO TD

Post  Magic 2/8/2009, 11:13 pm

NBC just keeps showing the replays from the out of bounds endzone camera and the long view from the other side but several times now I have seen the view from the goal post side with a close shot at his feet and that right foot doesn't touch the turf.

I am trying to find that on the web and all NBC shows are the bad angle shots that of course are not enough to change the call on the review of that play.

His left toe is all that hit the ground inbounds.

Scam mischief


Bookie Challenge
Original Rookie of the Year
BC CHAMPION 2018
BC CHAMPION 2019
BC CHAMPION 2024
Many time Rudy Award Winner
Bookie Challenge Hall of Fame
https://tinyurl.com/OfficialBookieChallenge
https://tinyurl.com/Official-Bookie-Challenge
Magic
Magic
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 8835
Age : 66
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

http://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Administrator 2/10/2009, 8:03 am

Which play are you talking about? I still haven't watched the whole game. I fast-forwarded to the porno clip at the end lol


BOOKIE CHALLENGE After further review I say NO TD 2-8110
Rest In Peace Garth
Administrator
Administrator
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 2562
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

https://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Magic 2/10/2009, 8:17 am

mighty_colts wrote:Which play are you talking about? I still haven't watched the whole game. I fast-forwarded to the porno clip at the end lol

The most important play in the game......the game winning TD with 35 seconds left.

Left toe hits the ground and the right toe is a couple inches above the turf and then he flys out of bounds.

It is natural for a right handed person to jump off the left foot and then land on the left foot first.

NBC sucks as usual and just over and over shows the camera angle that doesn't show the right foot since it is slightly behind the left foot.

Not that they will change the final score.

(or the actual MVP)



Bookie Challenge
Original Rookie of the Year
BC CHAMPION 2018
BC CHAMPION 2019
BC CHAMPION 2024
Many time Rudy Award Winner
Bookie Challenge Hall of Fame
https://tinyurl.com/OfficialBookieChallenge
https://tinyurl.com/Official-Bookie-Challenge
Magic
Magic
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 8835
Age : 66
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

http://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  cravnravn 2/10/2009, 9:06 am

After further review I say NO TD XrjW1CdrKjjsiju834rZ28lqo1_400
cravnravn
cravnravn
Retired

Number of posts : 5888
Age : 63
Location : Deltona, FL, Fizzled Out
Registration date : 2006-08-23

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  kobesgame 2/10/2009, 10:31 am

kobesgame
kobesgame
Retired

Number of posts : 345
Registration date : 2006-08-28

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Magic 2/10/2009, 4:42 pm

Of course the Steelers show you a blurry picture that doesn't actually show what you can see in that picture Cravn posted for us.

THAT is as close as his right foot came to hitting the turf!!

(btw thanks Cravn)


Bookie Challenge
Original Rookie of the Year
BC CHAMPION 2018
BC CHAMPION 2019
BC CHAMPION 2024
Many time Rudy Award Winner
Bookie Challenge Hall of Fame
https://tinyurl.com/OfficialBookieChallenge
https://tinyurl.com/Official-Bookie-Challenge
Magic
Magic
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 8835
Age : 66
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

http://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Administrator 2/10/2009, 7:20 pm

Ok, I'll check it out when I watch the game.

If that play had been ruled incomplete, the Steelers would have kicked a field goal and the game would have gone into overtime!! Then the BC Championship would have come down to the OverTime Coin Toss!!!

Magic, you had Heads......so did Kobe, Cravn and SA.
But I had Tails.


Wow.


BOOKIE CHALLENGE After further review I say NO TD 2-8110
Rest In Peace Garth
Administrator
Administrator
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 2562
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

https://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Magic 2/10/2009, 10:55 pm

Lot more to it than that Mighty!

Because I say the Cards would have won and of course Warner would have got the MVP and a couple other things would have changed too!!

2nd time I went into SB sunday with the lead.

But it isn't as bad as a certain time when I picked the Lambs to win sucks


......maybe I was just waiting for the 10th Annual wink


Bookie Challenge
Original Rookie of the Year
BC CHAMPION 2018
BC CHAMPION 2019
BC CHAMPION 2024
Many time Rudy Award Winner
Bookie Challenge Hall of Fame
https://tinyurl.com/OfficialBookieChallenge
https://tinyurl.com/Official-Bookie-Challenge
Magic
Magic
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 8835
Age : 66
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

http://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  cravnravn 2/11/2009, 3:01 am

No way Magic..Holmes had MVP wrapped up..Thats 2 years Ive selected the MVP..Both times the Stealers were in the Bowl, I picked Ward in 06.
cravnravn
cravnravn
Retired

Number of posts : 5888
Age : 63
Location : Deltona, FL, Fizzled Out
Registration date : 2006-08-23

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Magic 2/11/2009, 12:30 pm

smile No way Cravn!

Without that scam TD Holmes just had some yards and you don't get the MVP for that.

Cards would have won and since Warner already had 3 TD passes HE would have won the MVP!!!

Btw I just picked back to back SB MVP's here the 2 years before this one!!

BOTH Mannings!!

king


Bookie Challenge
Original Rookie of the Year
BC CHAMPION 2018
BC CHAMPION 2019
BC CHAMPION 2024
Many time Rudy Award Winner
Bookie Challenge Hall of Fame
https://tinyurl.com/OfficialBookieChallenge
https://tinyurl.com/Official-Bookie-Challenge
Magic
Magic
Bookie Challenge Emperor/Treasurer/Moderator

Number of posts : 8835
Age : 66
Location : Mount Zion
Registration date : 2006-08-20

http://tinyurl.com/Original-Bookie-Challenge

Back to top Go down

After further review I say NO TD Empty Re: After further review I say NO TD

Post  Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum